Mythical Wizard Tattoo

Nicole Witt — 5/5 (via Google) Sep 8, 2025

Casey is amazing!! He’s done basically all of my tattoos and I wouldn’t have it any other way! He’s such a great artist and just fun to talk to when getting tattooed. I love collaborating with him on my next tattoos and his flash pieces are so cool, I would get all of them if I could! I will always recommend him when people ask for recommendations!

Hallie Cusick — 5/5 (via Google) Sep 8, 2025

Casey is AMAZING. So very talented and easy to work with. My first tattoo by him was a custom piece and he nailed it! Exactly what I wanted, but even more detailed. There is a delicate aspect to parts of the shading and crisp line work. Both of my tattoos from Casey have healed beautifully and I am definitely going back! Not only is Casey crazy talented, they are the coolest person; funny, sweet and down to earth. Made it easy to relax in the chair and just let them do their thing. The shop itself is clean and has its own personality which is eclectic and fun. Definitely worth checking out!

Josh Skeels — 5/5 (via Google) Jun 6, 2025

Annie did an amazing job on a commemorative tattoo. She added her own personal creativity to my simple design and the results are beautiful! She was very attentive to detail, making sure the placement was exact and straight. The shop itself was super clean and had a really chill vibe. All the artists were super friendly, we talked about horror movies and the time absolutely flew by. I would recommend Mythical Wizard and Annie specifically, great little tattoo shop in sobro area of Indy. Definitely will be back, and can’t wait!

Abigail Reed — 5/5 (via Google) Dec 8, 2025

Devan did an amazing job on my snake skeleton! Very welcoming and friendly. Knows what he is doing and gives great advice! Definitely coming back:)